Home » Feature Film »General Content »Indie Reviews »Movie Reviews »Steve Pulaski »Trailers » Currently Reading:

Black Nativity

Black

“…the presence of pop culture stars such as Jennifer Hudson, Mary J. Blige and Nas, only add to the overly-glossy, bombastic nature of the film as a whole.”

I was buying most of what Kasi Lemmons’ adaptation of Langston Hughes’ poem Black Nativity was selling, admiring its inclusion of common problems facing the black community and the treacherous circumstances many face, until it basically solves the most unprecedented conflict by basically saying the words “forgiveness” and “be grateful” over and over again.

There are two common problems I see with films bearing a heavy religious denouement. One is they are out of touch with realism, making the villains out to be cliche, evil archetypes and the moral souls innocent angels, portraying their way of religious righteousness to be the only path to live ones’ life successfully. The other is that they become overbearing in their message, hamming home personal ideology or tired Christian philosophy, turning their films into feature-length lectures rather than films and making their characters cheap vessels for their ideology. Black Nativity‘s immediate issue is that it’s a mixture of both, but at the same time, a vast oversimplification of conflicts and contemporary issues in the typical African-American family. While the issues stretch a mile wide, the film gives them maybe five inches.

Black Nativity
Directed by
Kasi Lemmons
Cast
Forest Whitaker, Angela Bassett, Jennifer Hudson
Release Date
27 November 2013
Steve’s Grade: D+

The film concerns teenage Langston (played by the talented young Jacob Latimore), named after the famous poet, who I remember religiously studying and adoring back in fourth grade. Langston is having serious family issues with an absent father and a struggling mother (Jennifer Hudson), who sends him to live with his grandparents (Forest Whitaker and Angela Bassett) in the big city for the time being. Langston is a pretty secular kid, which is frowned upon by his grandparents, who feel that he is in dire need of a moral compass.

Interrupting myself, this is another reason that turns me off from these films. It’s unfair to constantly portray somebody who doesn’t have any particular religion as a heathen or a “lost” youth in society. Or even worse, a societal degenerate who constantly meanders between controlled to unpredictable. The act itself is shortchanging to the fact that just because one has a religion they cling to doesn’t immediately make them a good person all around; or even superior to non-believers.

Moreover, young Langston still has issues with his absent father, which the film doesn’t hesitate to rightly amplify as this being a huge issue in the black community, next to drug-dependency and the birth of children out-of-wedlock. However, he finds interest in the mysterious, petty street thug Tyson (Tyrese Gibson), who Langston meets in prison for a misunderstanding involving a lost wallet. Armed with his cold honesty and his grandparents’ reliance on the church’s teachings, Langston receives an experience of divine intervention he’ll never forget. On the contrary, the likelihood we, the audience member, will forget this particular film is pretty high.


As stated, Black Nativity (which I may add is produced by the famed Bishop T.D. Jakes) is another religious movie that feels that by repeating such words as “forgiveness,” “gratefulness,” and “blessed” is a way of solving a serious problem. What writer/director Kasi Lemmons forgets is that the aforementioned words are easily devalued, and using them roughly twenty times in the last fifteen minutes of the film, when the conflict escalates into absurd and irreparable heights, is not a particularly wise decision; especially when the conflict is as serious and disgusting as it is…

It’s also worth noting that the presence of pop culture stars such as Jennifer Hudson, Mary J. Blige (an angel in church), and Nas only add to the overly-glossy, bombastic nature of the film as a whole. Black Nativity has a considerable heart, and gets points for at least having a will and ambition to recognize harsh problems facing the black community in general, but it’s far too shortchanging and plagued by the niceness of its own conclusion.

When it comes to holiday films boasting an ensemble cast made up largely of black talents, I can only hope A Madea Christmas is better, and when that happens, one can only sense my lack of faith for a particular genre in film.

Review by Steve Pulaski, Lead Film Critic

VN:F [1.9.22_1171]
Seen it? Then Rate this Movie or Show!
Rating: 1.0/5 (1 vote cast)
posted on November 30, 2013

Comment on this Article:

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Choose a Category

Advertisement:

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Keep in mind, we may update multiple times daily.

Advertisements

AdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisementAdvertisement

Follow us on Twitter

Recent Comments

  • Jodi Stockton: Thank you so much for this review. It is so wonderful when s...
  • shawn chevalier: It's reviews like this that make the hearts of movie makers ...
  • William Conklin: Thank you so much for the wonderful review, Bethany! It mea...
  • rachel digiovanni: Well said! We are all looking forward to seeing Expect Delay...
  • Susan Blakey: This sounds like a story that anyone can relate to. We all ...

The Latest from Jason Howard

Nic Cage 2
An Interview with Nicolas Cage

  In this first installment of our series of chats with the cast and crew of Left Behind, we open with Oscar-winner More→

Galaxy
Guardians of the Galaxy (Review)

"Seeing it was like watching whatever movie that my 12-year-old self freaked out over on that very day in that particular More→

The Latest from Nav Qateel

Danger Dolls (2014) xYa2xfrp3IE
Danger Dolls (Review)

  "I was most impressed with the fight choreography as not all was down to overly-zealose editing, as is the norm Continue→

Don't Blink LrNfPlU_qsQ
Don’t Blink (Review)

  "In his inaugural film, director Travis Oates examines how a group cope in a high-pressure situation where they Continue→

The Latest from Steve Pulaski

Boxtrolls
The Boxtrolls (Review)

  "The Boxtrolls represents the stop-motion subgenre of films well because of the fact that it's uncompromising in More→

Tusk (2014) JVUJWSBkARg
Tusk (Review)

  "However, despite its comedic roots being clear and identifiable, make no mistake, Tusk is also a dark comedy. More→

Martin's Blog

Pre-Code2
The Golden Era of Pre-Code Films Part 2

Far Better and Far More Exciting the First Time Around.... The Mouthpiece (1932) Grade: A The Man Who Talked too Much More→

kiss meets the phantom of the park x9HWXi7jnIg
Martin’s, You Ain’t Seen Nothin’ Yet! – KISS Meets the Phantom of the Park

  Hello and welcome to another installment of my "You Ain't Seen Nothin' Yet" series for Influx. After years of More→

Reviews from Ed Blackadder

Boardwalk Empire 5
Boardwalk Empire: Season 5, Ep 02 (Recap)

The Good Listener (Warning, Spoilers) Nucky is now on the hunt for the person or person's that Read More→

Boardwalk Empire 5
Boardwalk Empire: Season 5, Ep 01 (Recap)

Golden Days for Boys and Girls (Warning, Spoilers) Do any of you remember the advice given to Read More→

The Latest from Rob Rector

Obvious
Obvious Child (Review)

  "While its central topic may be bold and daring, Obvious Child deserves its credit for perhaps providing us with Continue→

The Drop
The Drop (Review)

  "Like Drive or Killing Them Softly, The Drop is more interested on its characters than on plot twists or big Continue→

Recent articles from Bethany Rose

Expect Delays
Expect Delays (Review)

  "Expect Delays will make you laugh, cry, and think, without ever feeling taken advantage of. Rather than toy with Continue→

Marion Ross
An Interview with Actress Marion Ross

I recently spoke with actress Marion Ross, who everyone will remember as Happy Days' very own Mrs. C, a character she would Continue→

INFLUX Interview:

Advertisement:

Honda's Project Drive-In

Check it out!

Check it out!
Sons of Anarchy — The Hamlet Conclusion: Revisited
Sons of Anarchy — The Hamlet Conclusion: Revisited

Great reviews, interviews, articles and more!

Check out this week’s feature from Influx Magazine!

Read Article

In the Spotlight:

In the Spotlight:
An Interview with Yvonne Strahovski
An Interview with Yvonne Strahovski

Great interviews.

Great articles.

Great reviews.

We’ve got it all on INFLUX Magazine.

Get the insight you want from our writers!

Read More

Brian's Brain: Stark v. Kennedy

Hot on Influx Magazine:

Hot on Influx Magazine:
An Interview with Actor William Sadler
An Interview with Actor William Sadler

From established A-listers to up-and-comers, from the names you know, to the names you will know, read INFLUX the latest Influx Interviews.

Need more?

We have more.

Continue!

Influx Magazine Presents:

Influx Magazine Presents:
King Lear (Theatre)
King Lear (Theatre)

Check out this featured article from Influx Magazine.

We bring you great articles, exclusive interviews and the latest reviews.

Continue

Influx Exclusive Interview:

Influx Exclusive Interview:
An Interview with Actor Crispin Glover
An Interview with Actor Crispin Glover

INFLUX Interviews offer unique insight into the world of actors, directors, producers, musicians and many others in the various worlds of entertainment.

Check out our latest interviews and enjoy!

Continue

INFLUX Interviews

Nic Cage 2
An Interview with Nicolas Cage

  In this first installment of our series of chats with the cast and crew of Left Behind, we open with Oscar-winner More→

Marion Ross
An Interview with Actress Marion Ross

I recently spoke with actress Marion Ross, who everyone will remember as Happy Days' very own Mrs. C, a character she would More→

Kristina Anapau
An Interview with Actress Kristina Anapau

Theatrically trained at London's Royal Academy, no less, model turned actress/writer Kristina Anapau, graciously spoke to More→

MaryB
An Interview with Actress Mary Elizabeth Boylan

Actress and writer Mary Elizabeth Boylan has been building up a steady and enviable list of film credits since 2008, when More→

GeoCast
An Interview with ‘Geographically Desirable’ Writer/Director Mike Kravinsky and Actress Blair Bowers

Interviews with Mike Kravinsky and Blair Bowers I recently spoke to writer/director Mike Kravinsky and actress Blair More→

Eric G
An Interview with Actor Eric Goins (AMC’s Halt and Catch Fire)

  Actor Eric Goins plays Larry in the new popular drama Halt and Catch Fire from AMC. The show features the talents More→

Everybody Loves a List!

Camera
Top 10 Best Films For Cinematography (List)

We are accustomed to seeing a movie because a star, director or we have to see latest sequel, prequel or remake of a sequel More→

Cuckoo
Top 10 Best Picture Winners (List)

  The constant debate over what film won Best Picture, what film did not or which film got snubbed of a nomination More→

10 Supporting actors
10 Movies with Supporting Actor Oscar Nominees (List)

On many lists they concentrate on only the winners. Here, attention is drawn to the performances that helped escalate a More→

s2Member®