His & Hers proves that even a messy story can be worth the ride when the performances are this strong, even if the final destination does not fully deliver.
Netflix’s His & Hers is another glossy, adult-leaning prestige miniseries that mostly works on performance and mood, even when the story strains credibility.
Positioned somewhere in the same psychological neighborhood as Untamed, though not quite reaching those heights, His & Hers thrives on atmosphere, fractured perspectives, and moral decay. It is a slow-burn relationship thriller that wants to unsettle rather than comfort, and for the most part, it succeeds.
The biggest hurdle is the characters themselves. Nearly everyone here is deeply unlikeable, and worse, they make consistently poor decisions. One bad choice stacks onto the next, creating a domino effect that feels intentional but often frustrating. This is a show that dares you to keep watching people you do not particularly want to root for, which will test some viewers’ patience.
Thankfully, the performances do much of the heavy lifting. Jon Bernthal brings surprising warmth to Jack, managing to make the character emotionally accessible even when his actions suggest otherwise. Bernthal has always excelled at portraying wounded, volatile men, and he leans into that strength here.
Pablo Schreiber offers a subdued and quietly compelling turn, playing against his more physically imposing screen persona. Tessa Thompson anchors the series with confidence and gravity, while Sunita Mani makes a strong impression, adding texture and nuance whenever she appears.
Narratively, the series builds toward a climax that initially feels predictable, almost comforting in its familiarity. Then comes a late twist that is bold and intriguing, though not entirely viable once you start examining the logic behind it. The emotional impact lands in the moment, but the cracks in the story become clearer afterward.
Despite its flaws, His & Hers remains an enjoyable and binge-worthy watch. The pacing is confident, the tone is controlled, and the cast elevates material that could have easily collapsed under its own weight. It may fall short of true prestige greatness, but it is engaging enough to keep you watching until the end.
Gordo’s Score: 7.5/10
